Alan Weisman: The World Without Us (2007, Thomas Dunne
Books)
The basic concept here is to explore what would happen to the world
if by some unspecified happenstance human beings suddenly vanished,
leaving all of our artifacts and effects intact. The concept allows
for extensive exploration of those artifacts and effects, a mirror
image of how we have change nature, an unorthodox view of how the
world works.
Much of this is fascinating. The few quotes are rather scattered.
(pp. 39-40):
The last glacier left New York 11,000 years ago. Under normal
conditions, the next to flatten Manhattan would be due any day now,
though there's growing doubt that it will arrive on schedule. Many
scientists now guess that the current intermission before the next
frigid act will last a lot longer, because we've managed to postpone
the inevitable by stuffing our atmospheric quilt with extra
insulation. Comparisons to ancient bubbles in Antarctic ice cores
reveal there's more CO2 floating around today than at any
time in the past 650,000 years. If people cease to exist tomorrow and
whenever send another carbon-bearing molecule skyward, what we've
already set in motion must still play itself out.
That won't happen quickly by our standards, although our standards
are changing, because we Homo sapiens didn't bother to wait
until fossilization to enter geologic time. By becoming a veritable
force of nature, we've already done so. Among the human-crafted
artifacts that will last the longest after we're gone is our
redesigned atmosphere. Thus, Tyler Volk finds nothing strange about
being an architect teaching atmospheric physics and marine chemistry
on the New York University biology faculty. He finds he must draw on
all those disciplines to describe how humans have turned the
atmosphere, biosphere, and the briny deep into something that, until
now, only volcanoes and colliding continental plates have been able to
achieve.
Volk is a lanky man with wavy dark hair and eyes that scrunch into
crescents when he ponders. Leaning back in his chair, he studies a
poster as a single fluid with layers of deepening density. Until about
200 years ago, carbon dioxide from the gaseous part above dissolved
into the liquid part below at a steady rate that kept the world at
equilibrium. Now, with atmospheric CO2 levels so high, the
ocean needs to readjust. But because it's so big, he says, that takes
time.
"Say there are no more people buring fuel. At first, the ocean's
surface will absorb CO2 rapidly. As it saturates, that
slows, It loses some CO2 to photosynthesizing
organisms. Slowly, as the seas mix, it sinks, and ancient, unsaturated
water rises from the depths to replace it."
It takes 1,000 years for the ocean to completely turn over, but
that doesn't bring the Earth back to pre-industrial purity. Ocean and
atmosphere are more in balance with each other, but both are still
supercharged with CO2. So is the land, where excess carbon
will cycle through soil and life-forms that absorb but eventually
release it. So where can it go? "Normally," says Volk, "the biosphere
is like an upside-down glass jar: On top, it's basically closed to any
extra matter, except for letting in a few meteors. At the bottom, the
lid is slightly open -- to volcanoes."
The problem is, by tapping the Carboniferous Formation and spewing
it up into the sky, we've become a volcano that hasn't stopped
erupting since the 1700s.
Varosha, in Cyprus, appears in the book as a town that has been
abandoned due to civil war, its luxury tourist hotels left to decay as
would a world without us (pp. 92-93):
After World War I finished off the Ottomans, Cyprus ended up as a
British colony. The island's Greeks, Orthodox Christians who had
periodically revolted against the Ottoman Turks, weren't thrilled to
have British rulers instead, and clamored for unification with
Greece. The Turkish Cypriot Muslim minority protested. Tensions boiled
for decades and erupted viciously several times during the 1950s. A
1960 compromise resulted in the independent Republic of Cyprus, with
power shared between Greeks and Turks.
Ethnic hatred, however, had by then become a habit: Greeks
massacred entire Turkish families, and Turks ferociously avenged
them. A military takeover in Greece detonated a coup on the island,
midwifed by the American CIA in honor of Greece's new anticommunist
rulers. That prompted Turkey in July 1974 to send troops to protect
Turkish Cypriots from being annexed by Greece. During the ensuing
brief war, each side was accused of inflicting atrocities on the
other's civilians. When the Greeks placed anti-aircraft guns atop a
high-rise in the seaside resort of Varosha, Turkish bombers attacked
in American-made jets, and Varosh'a Greeks ran for their lives.
(p. 103):
Dr. Sözen sees this difference through an engineer's eyes. Whereas
all the previous conquering cultures erected fabulous monuments to
themselves like the Hagia Sophia and the nearby ethereal Blue Mosque,
the architectural expression of today's hordes is manifest in more
than 1 million multi-story buildings jammed into Istanbul's narrow
streets -- buildings that he says are doomed to abbreviated life
spans. In 2005, Sözen and a team he assembled of international
architectural and seismic experts warned the Turkish government that
within 30 years, the North Anatolian Fault that runs just east of the
city will slip again. When it does, at least 50,000 apartment
buildings will fall.
He's still awaiting a response, although he doubts that anyone can
imagine where to begin to stave off what his expertise deems
inevitable. In September 1985, the U.S. government rushed Sözen to
Mexico City to analyze how its embassy had weathered an 8.1-magnitude
earthquake that collapsed nearly 1,000 buildings. The highly
reinforced embassy, which he had examined a year earlier, was
intact. Up and down Avenida Reforma and adjacent streets, however,
many high-rise offices, apartments, and hotels had disintegrated.
It was one of the worst quakes in Latin American history. "But it
was mostly confined to downtown. What occurred in Mexico City is a
flake of what will happen to Istanbul."
Polymers Are Forever (p. 123):
During his first 1,000-mile crossing of the [North Pacific] gyre,
Moore calculated half a pound for every 100 square meters of debris on
the surface, and arrived at 3 million tons of plastic. His estimate,
it turned out, was corroborated by U.S. Navy calculations. It was the
first of many staggering figures he would encounter. And it only
represented visible plastic: an indeterminate amount of larger
fragments get fouled by enough algae and barnacles to sink. In 1998,
More returned with a trawling device, such as Sir Alistair Hardy had
employed to sample krill, and found, incredibly, more plastic by
weight than plankton on the ocean's surface.
In fact, it wasn't even close: six times as much.
(p. 136):
When something malfunctions, the results, unfortunately, can be
spectacular. In 1998, Sterling Chemical expelled a cloud of various
benzene isomers and hydrochloric acid that hospitalized hundreds. That
followed a leak of 3,000 pounds of ammonia four years earlier that
prompted 9,000 personal injury suits. In March 2005, a geyser of
liquid hydrocarbons erupted from one of BP's isomerization
stacks. When it hit the air, it ignited and killed 15 people. That
July, at the same plant, a hydrogen pipe exploded; in August, a gas
leak reeking of rotten eggs, which signals toxic hydrogen sulfide,
shut much of BP down for a while. Days later, at a BP
plastics-manufacturing subsidiary 15 miles south at Chocolate Bayou,
flames exploded 50 feet in the air. The blaze had to be left to burn
itself out. It took three days.
(p. 199):
As a professional birding guide, Hilty has watched the decline of
songbirds tilt into a plunge that has even nonbirders noticing the
deepening silence. Among the missing in his native Missouri is our
only blue-backed, white-throated warbler. Cerulean warblers used to
depart the Ozarks each fall for mid-elevation Andean forests in
Venezuela, Colombia, and Ecuador. With more of those being cut each
year for coffee -- or coca -- hundreds of thousands of arriving birds
must funnel into an ever-shrinking wintering ground, where there isn't
enough to feed them all.
(p. 200):
The birds that manage to survive on islands, as Charles Darwin
momentously observed among finches in the Galápagos, can adapt so
tightly to local conditions that they become species unto themselves,
found nowhere else. Those conditions explode, however, once humans
arrive with their pigs, goats, dogs, cats, and rats.
In Hawaii, all the roast feral pig devoured in luaus can't keep up
with the mayhem their rooting wreaks on forests and bogs. To protect
exotic sugarcane from being eaten by exotic rats, in 1883 Hawaiian
growers imported the exotic mongoose. Today, rats are still around:
the favorite food of both the rat and the mongoose is the eggs of the
few native geese and nesting albatrosses left on Hawaii's main
islands. In Guam, just after World War II, a U.S. transport plane
landed bearing stowaway Australian brown tree snakes in its
wheel-wells. Within three decades, along with several native lizards,
more than half the island's bird species were extinct, and the rest
designated uncommon or rare.
When we humans become extinct ourselves, part of our legacy will
live on in the predators we introduced. For most, the only constraints
on their rampant proliferation have been the eradication programs with
which we've tried to undo our damage. When we go, those efforts go
with us, and rodents and mongooses will inherit most of the South
Pacific's lovely isles.
(pp. 201-202):
As befits a chain reaction, it happened very fast. In 1938, a
physicist named Enrico Fermi went from Fascist Italy to Stockholm to
accept the Nobel Prize for his work with neutrons and atomic nuclei --
and kept going, defecting with his Jewish wife to the United
States.
That same year, word leaked that two German chemists had split
uranium atoms by bombarding them with neutrons. Their work confirmed
Fermi's own experiments. He had guessed correctly that when neutrons
cracked an atomic nucleus, they would set more neutrons free. Each
would scatter like a subatomic shotgun pellet, and with enough uranium
handy, they would find more nuclei to destroy. The process would
cascade, and a lot of energy would be released. He suspected Nazi
Germany would be interested in that.
On December 2, 1942, in a squash court beneath the stadium at the
University of Chicago, Fermi and his new American colleagues produced
a controlled nuclear chain reaction. Their primitive reactor was a
beehive-shaped pile of graphite bricks laced with uranium. By
inserting rods coated with cadmium, which absorbs neutrons, they could
moderate the exponential shattering of uranium atoms to keep it from
getting out of hand.
Less than three years later, in the New Mexico desert, they did
just the opposite. The nuclearn reaction this time was intended to go
completely out of control. Immense energy was released, and within a
month the act was repeated twice, over two Japanese cities. More than
100,000 people died instantly, and the dying continued long after the
initial blast. Ever since, the human race has been simultaneously
terrified and fascinated by the double deadliness of nuclear fission:
fantastic destruction followed by slow torture.
(p. 207):
The first site to begin shipping to WIPP [Waste Isolation Pilot
Plant, a nuclear waste repository in New Mexico] was Rocky flats, a
defense facility on a foothills plateau 16 miles northwest of
Denver. Until 1989, the United States made plutonium detonators for
atomic weapons at Rocky Flats with somewhat less than a lawful regard
for safety. For years, thousands of drums of cutting oil saturated
with plutonium and uranium were stacked outside on bare ground. When
someone finally noticed they were leaking, asphalt was poured over the
evidence. Radioactive runoff at Rocky Flats frequently reached local
streams; cement was swirled into radioactive sludge in absurd attempts
to try to slow seepage from cracked evaporation ponds; and radiation
periodically escaped into the air. A 1989 FBI raid finally closed the
place. In the new millennium, after several billion dollars' worth of
intensive cleanup and public relations, Rocky Flats was transmutted
into a National Wildlife Refuge.
Simultaneously, similar alchemy was recasting the old Rocky
Mountain Arsenal next to Denver International Airport. RMA was a
chemical-weapons plant that made mustard and nerve gas, incendiary
bombs, napalm -- and during peacetime, insecticides; its core was once
called the most contaminated square mile on Earth. After dozens of
wintering bald eagles were found in its security buffer, feasting on
the prodigious prairie dog population, it, too, became a National
Wildlife Refuge. That required draining and sealing an Arsenal lake
where ducks once died moments after landing, and where the bottoms of
aluminum boats sent to fetch their carcasses rotted within a
month. Although the plan is to treat and monitor toxic groundwater
plumes for another century until they're considered safely diluted,
today mule deer big as elk find asylum where humans once feared to
tread.
(p. 266):
Within recent historic times, reefs swarmed with 800-pound
groupers, codfish could be dipped from the sea by lowering baskets,
and oysters filtered all the water in Chesapeake Bay every three
days. The planet's shores teemed with millions of manatees, seals, and
walruses. Then, within a pair of centuries, coral reefs were flattened
and sea-grass beds were scraped bare, the New Jersey-sized dead zone
appeared off the mouth of the Mississippi, and the world's cod
collapsed.
Yet despite mechanized overharvesting, satellite fish-trackers,
nitrate flooding, and prolonged butchery of sea mammals, the ocean is
still bigger than we are. Sine prehistoric man had no way to pursue
them, it's the one place on Earth besides Africa where big creatures
eluded the intercontinental megafaunal extinction. "The great majority
of sea species are badly depleted," says Jeremy Jackson, "but they
still exist. If people actually went away, most could recover."